What makes a town a smart buy in 2025? It’s more than just top-rated schools or a fast train to the city. Long-term value matters, especially in a market where every decision counts. Whether the goal is a forever home or a strategic resale, knowing where equity will grow is key.  

In Part 2 of our Midtown Direct series, we’re focusing on the future. Which towns are holding strong with buyer demand, steady appreciation, and proven market performance? Backed by price trends and expert insight, here’s where your real estate investment is most likely to pay off.

Northern New Jersey Real Estate Market Watch

Homes in Summit sold for an average of 107.2% of their list price as of August 2025. However, real estate trends in Northern New Jersey are constantly evolving. Contact The Saritte Harel Team for expert assistance in buying and selling homes in New Jersey.

 

Top NJ towns along the Midtown Direct Train Line for Resale Value and Market Strength

 

What Drives Resale Value in Northern New Jersey?

A strong resale market isn’t just about square footage or high-end finishes. A combination of factors shapes it:

• School quality and rankings
• Proximity to NYC and reliable train access
• Downtown development and overall lifestyle appeal
• Low inventory and steady buyer demand
• Historical appreciation and fast sales cycle

These factors combine to determine which towns retain their value and which ones rise quickly in competitive seller markets.

 

Top Towns for Home Resale Value in 2025

Town	5-Year Appreciation	Days on Market	Resale Strength
Millburn	+32%	14 days	🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Summit	+29%	16 days	🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Short Hills	+27%	18 days	🔥🔥🔥🔥
Maplewood	+28%	21 days	🔥🔥🔥🔥
Chatham	+26%	20 days	🔥🔥🔥🔥
South Orange	+24%	25 days	🔥🔥🔥

 

Notes:

• 5-Year Appreciation values are based on median home sale price trends from recent market reports (e.g., MLS, Zillow, or Redfin data). Actual appreciation will vary depending on property type, size, and neighborhood.
• Days on Market (DOM) represents the median time homes spent listed before going under contract in 2024–2025. These values fluctuate by season, property price point, and buyer demand.
• Resale Strength (🔥 scale) is a relative indicator created to show how quickly homes resell compared to neighboring markets. It is not an official index but reflects a combination of appreciation, DOM, and buyer demand.

 

Millburn & Summit: The Gold Standard in Resale

These towns continue to lead the market, thanks to their top-rated schools, express train access, and strong community appeal. Homes in Millburn and Summit often go under contract within days. High-quality listings continue to spark bidding wars, even as the market shifts.

• Millburn: Limited inventory keeps prices strong. Well-staged homes often sell above asking.
• Summit: Historic charm and walkability fuel year-round buyer interest and steady demand.

 

Short Hills & Maplewood: Luxury and Lifestyle With ROI

Short Hills delivers long-term value for luxury buyers, particularly those seeking spacious homes near train lines and top schools. Meanwhile, Maplewood’s inclusive atmosphere and creative energy continue to attract buyers from Brooklyn and beyond.

• Short Hills: High price point, but move-in-ready homes sell quickly.
• Maplewood: Trendy and rapidly appreciating, especially in walkable neighborhoods near the town center.

 

Chatham, South Orange & Glen Ridge: Smart Buys With Upside

These towns combine strong livability with solid investment potential. All three have seen steady appreciation over the past five years and continue to attract families and value-driven buyers.

• Chatham: Excellent schools and a strong seller’s edge across most price points.
• South Orange: Gaining popularity with creatives and younger buyers.
• Glen Ridge: A quiet standout with timeless architecture and a classic suburban feel.

 

Expert Advice from Saritte Harel

"Buyers who focus only on the list price often miss the real value. The towns with the strongest resale performance usually offer three things: tight inventory, top-tier schools, and reliable train service. That’s the formula to watch."
— Saritte H.

 

FAQs on Resale Value and Investment Potential

Which NJ town along the Midtown Direct Train Line has the most substantial resale value in 2025?
Millburn and Summit are leading the pack in 2025. Low inventory, high demand, and top-rated schools keep these areas competitive in any market cycle.

Is Short Hills a good long-term investment?
Yes. Despite higher entry prices, homes in Short Hills hold their value well. The town continues to attract luxury buyers seeking NYC access, top schools, and a refined lifestyle.

What if the goal is growth potential rather than current value?
Consider Glen Ridge and South Orange. These neighborhoods are gaining momentum as more buyers head west from NYC, bringing demand and appreciation with them.

How long does it take to sell a home in Millburn or Summit?
In 2025, most well-prepared homes in Millburn and Summit are going under contract in under three weeks. Some sell within days of hitting the market.

Can resale value improve with renovations or timing?
Absolutely. Smart updates, market timing, and listing strategy make a big difference. Saritte’s Construction Concierge service helps sellers boost ROI before going to market.

 

Your Home is an Investment. Treat It Like One

A property's value isn’t just about today. Long-term potential matters too. Whether buying or selling, Saritte Harel and her team offer clear insights and a custom strategy to guide each step.

Schedule your resale value consultation now and take the first step toward a more profitable real estate move.