Every year, more New Yorkers trade high-rises for hometown charm in the New Jersey suburbs. However, finding the right neighborhood on the Midtown Direct line isn’t that simple. Some boast express trains and walkable downtowns. Others shine for their award-winning schools and tight-knit communities. The sweet spot sits where commute convenience meets lifestyle value, and that’s what this guide reveals.  

For 2025, we’ve ranked the top Midtown Direct towns based on two crucial factors: community feel and commute time to Penn Station. Whether working hybrid, raising a family, or escaping the city, this breakdown will help you find your perfect fit. Let’s dive into the places that nail both accessibility and livability, starting with what matters most to busy buyers.

Northern New Jersey Real Estate Market Watch

In August 2025, Short Hills' median home sale price rose 15.5% year-over-year. However, real estate trends in Northern New Jersey are constantly evolving. Contact The Saritte Harel Team for expert assistance in buying and selling homes in New Jersey.

 

Top Towns Ranked by Commute & Community

What Is the Midtown Direct Line and Why Does It Matter?

Running from Morris and Essex Counties straight into NYC’s Penn Station, the Midtown Direct is a game-changer. It’s one of the strongest forces driving home values and buyer interest in Northern New Jersey. Towns with direct train access attract more demand, higher prices, and faster appreciation, especially from Manhattan and Brooklyn buyers.

 

How We Ranked These Towns

We evaluated NJ towns along the Midtown Direct train line using two weighted categories:

• Commute Time – Travel minutes to NYC Penn Station during peak hours, express train availability, parking ease, and reliability.
  
• Community Feel – School quality, downtown amenities, walkability, neighborhood character, and overall livability.
  

 

Snapshot of 2025 Town Rankings

Town	Commute Time (to NYC Penn Station, Train)	Community Rating (Niche-based)	Key Highlights
Millburn	~45 min	10.0 (A+)	Top schools, walkable, charming downtown
Summit	~45 min	10.0 (A+)	Historic homes, upscale living, strong community culture
Short Hills	~38 min	10.0 (A+)	Luxury lifestyle, excellent schools
Maplewood	~35–40 min	9.5 (A / A+)	Trendy, vibrant, LGBTQ+ friendly
Chatham	~50 min	10.0 (A+)	Family-focused, elite schools
South Orange	~35–40 min	9.0 (A / A-)	Artsy, diverse, creative community

 

Notes:

• Commute Times are approximate train travel durations to NYC Penn Station via NJ Transit. Actual times vary based on peak/off-peak schedules, transfers, and service disruptions. Driving may differ significantly depending on traffic.
• Community Ratings are based on Niche.com overall grades for “Places to Live.” Letter grades were converted into a 10-point scale for consistency (A+ = 10.0, A = 9.0, A- = 8.5, etc.). Ratings represent a blend of schools, housing, diversity, and livability factors.
• These values are provided as general benchmarks for buyers and sellers. Personal experiences may vary based on lifestyle, priorities, and neighborhood specifics.

 

Best Towns for a Fast NYC Commute

If a quick trip to Penn Station is your top priority, Millburn, South Orange, and Short Hills deliver the fastest commutes. These communities benefit from express trains, ample parking, and proximity to the station from most neighborhoods.

• Millburn: 35-minute commute, reliable express service, walkable access to downtown and schools.
  
• Short Hills: Known for luxury estates and quick transit, perfect for executives and hybrid professionals.
  
• South Orange: Artsy and diverse, with fast trains and a welcoming atmosphere.
  

 

Best NJ town along the Midtown Direct Train Line for Community Feel

Community is where long-term value thrives. Buyers seeking top schools, parks, and lively main streets choose Summit, Chatham, and Maplewood.

• Summit: Refined and historic, with walkable streets and high-end retail.
  
• Chatham: One of NJ’s top-rated family towns, with a tight-knit, neighborly atmosphere.
  
• Maplewood: Creative and inclusive, celebrated for its cultural scene and stunning architecture.
  

 

Who Should Live Where?

• Hybrid Workers & Executives: Millburn, Short Hills
  
• Families: Chatham, Summit
  
• Creatives & Young Couples: Maplewood, South Orange
  
• Buyers Seeking Long-Term Value: Glen Ridge, Millburn
  

Each town offers a different blend of lifestyle and logistics. The choice comes down to what matters more, your commute or your community.

 

Midtown Direct Buyer FAQs

What is the fastest Midtown Direct train to NYC?
Millburn, Short Hills, and South Orange offer the shortest commutes with express trains to Penn Station, typically under 40 minutes.

Which NJ town along the Midtown Direct train line is best for families?
Chatham and Summit rank highest for family buyers thanks to excellent schools, safety, and walkable neighborhoods.

Do all towns have express trains?
No. While most have access to express service, frequency and speed vary. Millburn, South Orange, and Short Hills provide the most reliable options.

Is parking available at all Midtown Direct train stations?
Most stations offer permit and daily parking, but availability varies. Some towns have parking permit waitlists, so plan early.

Which town offers the best mix of commute and lifestyle?
Millburn ranks high for both a fast commute and a strong community feel, making it one of the most balanced choices.

 

Let’s Find the Best Town That Works for Your Lifestyle

No need to guess your way through the move. Whether relocating, upsizing, or making a strategic investment, Saritte Harel delivers local expertise, sharp negotiation, and exclusive off-market access.

Book your private consultation with Saritte’s team today and get a head start on your next step.