Short Hills, New Jersey, is one of the state’s most desirable suburban communities, known for its beautiful homes, nationally recognized schools, and proximity to New York City. Its combination of luxury living and small-town charm continues to attract professionals and families who value both convenience and lifestyle.

For those working in Manhattan, commuting remains an important factor when deciding to make Short Hills home. Fortunately, residents benefit from multiple reliable transportation options that connect directly to New York City. This guide explores the best ways to commute from Short Hills to NYC.

By Train

Short Hills residents have direct access to the Short Hills Train Station, part of NJ Transit’s Morris & Essex Line. The Midtown Direct service provides a straight shot into Penn Station in about 35 minutes during peak hours. Off-peak trains typically run closer to 40–45 minutes.

For added flexibility, the Millburn Station, just a short drive away, offers additional parking and frequent service along the same line.

In addition to direct service into Penn Station, commuters can also take trains from Short Hills directly into Hoboken Terminal (about 40 minutes during peak times). From Hoboken, the PATH train provides seamless access to Downtown Manhattan, including the World Trade Center and Wall Street. The PATH ride usually adds another 5–10 minutes, making this a convenient alternative for those working in New York’s financial district.

Train Frequency:
On weekday mornings between 5:30 am and 9:00 am, NJ Transit runs frequent Midtown Direct service from Short Hills and Millburn to Penn Station, with trains departing roughly every 20 minutes. Evening return service is equally consistent, with trains leaving Penn Station back to the suburbs every 15–20 minutes between 4:30 pm and 7:00 pm.

Parking:

• Short Hills Station: Primarily resident-only parking, though a new non-resident option was recently added.

• Millburn Station: Both resident and non-resident parking available, with a dedicated parking deck and no waitlist for resident permits.

By Boxcar Luxury Bus

For commuters who prefer a comfortable bus ride directly into Midtown or the Upper East Side, Boxcar operates its South Mountain Line with pickup spots at Short Hills Station, Millburn Station, Maplewood, and South Orange. Through the Boxcar app, commuters can also reserve daily parking spots at nearby businesses, eliminating the stress of station parking.

By Car

Driving from Short Hills into New York City is another option, though it comes with the usual traffic and toll considerations. The town’s proximity to major highways including Route 24, I-78, and the Garden State Parkway makes for straightforward access to Manhattan via the Holland Tunnel, Lincoln Tunnel, or George Washington Bridge.

Travel Times:

• Off-peak hours: ~35–45 minutes into Midtown.

• Rush hour: Typically 60+ minutes, depending on traffic.
  
  

By Ferry

While not directly served by a ferry terminal, many Short Hills commuters drive to nearby Jersey City ferry terminals. From there, NY Waterway and other services provide quick access to Midtown or Downtown Manhattan. This option is especially popular for those working near Wall Street or the Financial District.

Tips for Short Hills Commuters

• Midtown Direct Advantage: Few suburbs match Short Hills’ direct train service speed and frequency into NYC.

• Parking Strategy: Residents without permits can choose Millburn Station or Boxcar’s reserved spots.

• Backup Plan: Severe weather and transit delays can disrupt schedules thus having bus or carpool alternatives is wise.

• Family-Friendly Commuting: Many residents highlight the ease of living close to the station, making the morning commute more manageable.

For commuters to New York City, Short Hills offers one of the most seamless suburban commutes in New Jersey. With multiple train stations nearby, Boxcar luxury bus service, and direct highway access, you’ll have flexibility in how you travel to Manhattan.

If you’re considering a move to Short Hills, our team can help you find a home that not only fits your lifestyle but also offers a commute that works for you. Looking for homes in Short Hills with great commuting access? Contact The Saritte Harel Team today.

Short Hills to NYC: Frequently Asked Questions

Does Short Hills, NJ have a direct train to New York City?

Yes. NJ Transit’s Midtown Direct service runs from the Short Hills train station directly to Penn Station in Manhattan in about 35 minutes during peak hours.

How long is the commute from Short Hills to NYC by train?
On average, the train from Short Hills to Penn Station takes approximately 35 minutes. Commute times may vary slightly depending on the time of day and train schedule.

Are there bus options from Short Hills to New York City?
Yes. Boxcar offers luxury bus service from Short Hills, Millburn, Maplewood, and South Orange stations with stops in Midtown and the Upper East Side.

Can you drive from Short Hills to Manhattan?
Yes. Driving is possible via Route 24, I-78, or the Garden State Parkway, with access through the Holland Tunnel, Lincoln Tunnel, or George Washington Bridge. Travel time is around 35–45 minutes off-peak and 60+ minutes during rush hour.

Is parking available at the Short Hills train station?
Parking at Short Hills station is primarily resident-only, though non-resident options are limited. Millburn station nearby offers more flexibility with both resident and non-resident parking.